Have you been asked by your client to review your competitor’s report? It is an honor to conduct a geotechnical peer review and can be a critical step forward, or backward, in becoming the consultant of choice for your clients. This is a critical client touch moment, and as such it’s important to approach a peer review with the right mindset before proceeding.

所以你被要求进行岩土科的同行评审manbet万博app

想象一下，今天你进入办公室，你最喜欢的客户致电你讨论竞争对手准备的岩土工程报告。manbet万博app他们有一些问题并希望第二个意见。岩土学研究的成本可能是设计成manbet万博app本的一小部分，但可以对项目预算产生深远的影响。帮助同行评审的潜在客户可以成为增加信任和加强与良好客户的关系的重要第一步。为了创造能力，您必须展示完整性，并证明您的意图是真正帮助您的客户，而不仅仅是“看起来很好”。执行同行评审可能或可能不会导致即时收益，但最终可能为未来的工作提供途径。

“Performing a peer review may or may not result in an immediate payoff, but can ultimately provide a pathway to future work.”

在继续之前，您可能想问一些初步问题：

1. 我想参与这个项目吗？
2. 这个项目/地质在我的经验领域吗？
3. 此外，是否存在利益冲突？您是否与该项目的设计团队中与所有者或其他人都有现有的关系，这可能会产生负面影响？
4. Are there legal issues or litigation currently involved with the project? These are crucial questions that you must answer prior to moving forward.

扔掉你的前心概念

因此，您的客户告诉您他们怀疑竞争对手的报告是不知重好的，过于保守的，并且岩土工程师的历史记录不了解条件或市场。manbet万博app也许你有类似的遭遇。客户有时可能会聘请您提供新的研究，您与您与之交谈的人甚至会尝试利用您提供“价值工程“。

你的诚实、自我价值和professionalism are all tied to how you conduct a peer review, which is why it’s so important to take a step back and clear your mind. Rush decisions based on preconceived ideas can cloud your better judgment. Remember that your intent is to assist your client in finding a solution that matches their project. Your intent should never be to simply look good or to throw stones at a competitor. Would you wish others rush to a conclusion about you and your firm? Conducting yourself in a professional way will create an atmosphere of respect between yourself, your peers and your client.

“你的诚实，自我价值和专业性都与你的同行评论有关......”

It is highly likely that the format of a competitor firm’s report will differ from the format your firm uses. Be open to the report presentation. Your competitors’ report may provide new ideas. If you keep an open mind as you perform an initial review, you may learn something new, whether it be additional design options or, better yet, an improved way of presenting recommendations. Many times “poor recommendations” can be the result of the information gathering process or lack thereof. It is crucial that all pertinent information be obtained prior to and during a study. An engineer may not request this information or the information may simply not be provided or available. In addition, there may be changes to the project that are not made known to the geotechnical engineer of record.

“如果您在执行初始评论时保持开放性，您可以学习新的东西，无论是额外的设计选项还是更好，更好地提出了提出的建议。”

提供合理的时间表，避免无法实现的截止日期。鉴于该工程已经完成，设计现在准备去施工，它可能是匆忙。确保给予岩土考间审查值得的时间。manbet万博app不同意一个不允许您审查其应得的足够焦点和关注的时间范围。项目的大量资金和项目的成功或失败可能会受到威胁。避免使承诺尝试为您的意见立即返回，也不会要求此类。坚持事实 - 它将在长远来看你的优势。

Should I Inform My Peer that I am Performing a Review of Their Study?

I have several clients in San Antonio and throughout the state of Texas that routinely call with questions or to simply discuss another firm’s study or approach. When is it my duty to inform my counterpart at this other firm? Routine reviews to help your client interpret a report may not require you to notify the engineer of record. Once again, it is a matter of being respectful to your peers. If you are contracted to provide a formal review with a detailed commentary and to verify design calculations provided by another firm, you may be obligated by law to notify the engineer of record. Most licensing agencies have guidelines and rules on when it is appropriate to notify the other party.

How Do I Conduct a Geotechnical Peer Review in a Respectable, Professional Way?

有一些基本的，但重要的是记住岩土科对同行评审时的重要步骤。manbet万博app

1. 查看报告大纲（如果提供）（类似于执行内部报告审查）。
2. Evaluate whether the report is locally applicable. Is the report:
   • 由国家持牌工程师开发;
   • consistent with local geologic conditions;
   • 使用本地接受的设计方法和实践，最后;
   • 是否使用本地技术开发的建议？
3. 调查是否提供了成本效益的设计选项。
4. Confirm the design options are consistent with the soil conditions.
5. 确定建议是否清晰，精确，如果提出了多种选项，则每个选项定义的成本/性能优势是多少？

您进行岩土性同行评审的方法可以显示您的客户特征和能力，建立信manbet万博app任的关键要素。您的表现可以使您在您所在地区的公认权限，并帮助您对同行的差异。始终以完整性，尊严和最大尊重对该领域的同伴尊重的同行评审。